plugverdict

What earthing protects against

The earth pin carries no current when everything is working. That is exactly why a broken earth gives no sign at all: the device runs perfectly, right up until the fault it was there to catch.

What it is for

Inside an appliance with a metal body, one thing can go wrong that matters more than the others: a live conductor working loose, or insulation failing, and touching the chassis. The case is now at mains potential and looks completely normal.

With an earth connection, that fault has somewhere to go. Current flows from live to earth immediately, and it flows in a quantity that a breaker or an RCD notices — the circuit disconnects in milliseconds, usually before anyone has touched anything.

Without one, nothing happens. The chassis sits there energised and waits. The path to earth that eventually completes the circuit is whoever picks it up.

Class I and Class II: which of your things care

Appliances that rely on an earth for this protection are Class I. Appliances built so that a single insulation failure cannot energise anything touchable — two independent layers, or a plastic body with no exposed metal — are Class II, and they carry a square inside a square moulded into the casing. A Class II device has no earth pin because it does not want one.

Nearly everything with a two-pin figure-eight lead is Class II: chargers, shavers, laptop bricks. Of the 28 classes we track, 6 need an earth:

The pattern is not an accident. They are the things with a metal body, a heating element, or water in them, and often all three.

The part almost nobody publishes: plugs that fit and drop the earth

A plug fitting a socket and a plug being earthed by that socket are two separate questions, and the second one is not visible. There is no resistance, no wobble and no warning. We record it as its own column, and these are the 13 combinations on file where the plug goes in and the earth does not follow:

Plug Into socketWhy the earth is lost
Type AType BA Type A plug has no earth pin at all, so nothing gets earthed in a Type B socket. Only matters if the thing you are plugging in needs one
Type CType EA Type C plug has no earth pin at all, so nothing gets earthed in a Type E socket. Only matters if the thing you are plugging in needs one
Type CType FA Type C plug has no earth pin at all, so nothing gets earthed in a Type F socket. Only matters if the thing you are plugging in needs one
Type CType HA Type C plug has no earth pin at all, so nothing gets earthed in a Type H socket. Only matters if the thing you are plugging in needs one
Type CType JA Type C plug has no earth pin at all, so nothing gets earthed in a Type J socket. Only matters if the thing you are plugging in needs one
Type CType KA Type C plug has no earth pin at all, so nothing gets earthed in a Type K socket. Only matters if the thing you are plugging in needs one
Type CType LA Type C plug has no earth pin at all, so nothing gets earthed in a Type L socket. Only matters if the thing you are plugging in needs one
Type CType NA Type C plug has no earth pin at all, so nothing gets earthed in a Type N socket. Only matters if the thing you are plugging in needs one
Type CType OA Type C plug has no earth pin at all, so nothing gets earthed in a Type O socket. Only matters if the thing you are plugging in needs one
Type EType FA Type E plug expects an earth pin sticking out of the socket. A Type F socket hasn't got one, so it goes in and earths nothing. That mismatch is the whole reason the hybrid CEE 7/7 plug exists
Type FType EA Type F plug takes its earth from clips on the side. A Type E socket earths through a pin instead, so nothing meets. That mismatch is the whole reason the hybrid CEE 7/7 plug exists
Type KType EThe Danish earth pin has nothing to touch in a French socket
Type KType FThe Danish earth pin has nothing to touch in a Schuko socket

The Europlug is most of the list

A Type C plug has two pins and no earth contact anywhere on it, so it unearths in every earthed socket it fits — and it fits 8 of them: Type E, Type F, Type H, Type J, Type K, Type L, Type N, Type O. This is by far the most common way a traveller loses an earth without noticing, because the Europlug is also the most accommodating plug in Europe.

Schuko and French sockets earth by different mechanisms

The subtler entries are Type E and Type F, which look interchangeable and are not. A French Type E socket has an earth pin protruding from it, which mates with a socket in the plug. A German Type F Schuko earths through clips on the sides of the recess. Each plug fits the other's socket and finds nothing to connect to. The same applies to the Danish Type K, whose earth pin has nothing to touch in either.

What to do about it

The tool flags earth loss per device rather than per country, because it depends on which plug is on the end of your particular lead.

Related